Ronald Garafalo - John J Lease Realtors Logo
$2,500,000
 $13,421 est/mo Sourced by Back At You

51 Garden Street,Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Share:

PreviousNext

Description

Charming mid 1800s traditional perfectly situated within sight of Sag Harbor Cove and two blocks from the central business district on a double lot features a freestanding garage and room for a swimming pool. Original details and windows make this the historical restoration project about which you have always dreamed. Tucked away in a rear corner, the pre-existing and nonconforming siting of the outbuilding (with electric) frees generous portions of the already oversized lot. Imagine being several hundred meters from your boat. Picture your forays into the heart of Sag Harbor Village for your morning coffee, or your evening (restaurant) meal.

Details

MLS #1021365
Listing TypeFor Sale
StyleHouse
Sub-TypeResale
StatusActive
Year1900
Days On Site76
Listing Provided ByDouglas Elliman Real Estate | Raymond G. Lord III

Features

Bed(s)3
Bath(s) 1 Total
SQ Feet1,404
Garage1
BasementY
Story(s)2
Acreage0.18

Interior

CoolingNone
HeatingOil
Interior FeaturesEat-in Kitchen, Open Floorplan, Open Kitchen, Original Details
AppliancesConvection Oven, Cooktop, Dishwasher, Dryer, Freezer, Refrigerator

Exterior

Construction MaterialsFrame

Parking

Garage Yes / NoYes
Parking FeaturesDetached

Utilities

UtilitiesCable Connected, Electricity Connected, Natural Gas Connected
SewerSeptic Tank

Taxes

Tax Year2025
Tax Assessed Value922800
Tax Annual Amount5294

Area Information

StateNY
CountySuffolk County
CitySag Harbor
Zip Code11963
School DistrictPierson Middle/High School
Elementary SchoolSag Harbor Elementary School
High SchoolPierson Middle/High School
Listing VS Median (in 11963)
Price:
$2,500,000
low | high
Med:
$2,125,000
65% of Average
sqft:
1,404
low | high
Med:
2,222
8.262108262108% of Average
$ / sqft:
$1,781
low | high
Med:
$1,189
83.221374454847% of Average
On site:
76
low | high
Med:
100
76% of Average
Sourced by Back At You

Market Activity 11963

Request a showing

Request a showing

Contact

Additional Information

Showing Information

Submit Form

Required Field
By submitting, you agree to receive promotional texts and/or calls from John J Lease Realtors at the number provided. Message/data rates may apply. Consent is not a condition of purchase, and you can opt out anytime by replying STOP.
MLS Internet Data Exchange (IDX) information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and that the data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the OneKey® MLS

Contact

Learn More About This Property

Ronald Garafalo

Ronald Garafalo

John J Lease REALTORS

 (845) 283-1279rongarafalo@johnjleaserealtors.com
StateNY
CountySuffolk County
CitySag Harbor
Zip Code11963
School DistrictPierson Middle/High School
Elementary SchoolSag Harbor Elementary School
High SchoolPierson Middle/High School
Listing VS Median (in 11963)
Price:
$2,500,000
low | high
Med:
$2,125,000
65% of Average
sqft:
1,404
low | high
Med:
2,222
8.262108262108% of Average
$ / sqft:
$1,781
low | high
Med:
$1,189
83.221374454847% of Average
On site:
76
low | high
Med:
100
76% of Average
Sourced by Back At You
Nearby Listings (Within 1/2 mile)
Price: $1.875M - $3.125M
sqft: 1,000 - 1,500
Nearby Listings Property ImageNearby Listings Details
221 Division Street Property Photo 1
$2,849,000
221 Division Street
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Listing Updated: July 9, 2026 at 3:37:33 PM PDT

Ronald Garafalo - John J Lease Realtors